
I know Thanksgiving has come and gone and won't be around for several more months but after reading article about another FN host, I thought it was time to give thanks for Alton Brown and
Good Eats.
The article in question, from the
Milwaukee Journal-Sentintel, the one sending me to write this post was about "culinary diva" Sandra Lee and her new semi-horrific magazine. At first, the article gave me a chuckle. But as I reread it, looking for places to seize upon, I noticed how diametrically apposed my kitchen philosophy is to ol' Aunt Sandy's.
Here's the particular quote that bought on this post:
Q. Let's focus on the food part of it. What is it about your magazine that stands out?
A. Not only are my recipes time-conscious, they're also cost-conscious. I think it's an equal conundrum, money and time, when you're in the kitchen.
Other food magazines want to introduce you to new things to do - which is great, and occasionally I do that as well. But my job is to really do the research. I will be on the phone with SuperValu (grocery stores), and I will find out what Cub Foods' top 50 sell-through products are, so I know what's in your pantry.
So when I put together a recipe, it's with stuff that you already love, it's already in your pantry so you don't have to spend extra money. My job is to tell you four different ways to use it, and my job is to name it by brand. There's a ton of recipes, but what there's not out there is a ton of end success for the users. I do the brands within the recipe so you know to get this picture, you follow this recipe. It's Kraft this, it's McCormick seasoning that. Different products have different ingredient bases.
Dumbfounded. Me, not her. Besides, we all know she's dumb... wait... in an alcohol induced stupor. All I have to say is... WTF?
So, her job is to tell me "four different ways" to use things from the pantry? Would that be stirred, shaken, on the rock and straight up? Why four? I can name at least six dishes from my repertoire using canned tomatoes. Did she arbitrarily pick the number to match her IQ?
AND another part of her job is to specify what to use by brand name. Will the food police arrest someone for using a generic brand in one of her dishes?
My favorite line from the article, however, was this:
"There's a ton of recipes, but what there's not out there is a ton of end success for the users. [Whew, that's an awkwardly phrased sentence.] I do the brands within the recipe so you know to get this picture, you follow this recipe." Ah, so when a recipe doesn't turn out its because of not using the right brand. Oh thank you, thank you, thank you Sandra. I understand it so much now.
Barf.
Funny, I've tried a boatload of Alton's recipes from the show and his cookbooks over the years with excellent results. Many of them I have changed from the original version But... but how is it possible they turn out fine? AB doesn't say, "You must purchase brand X in order to get the proper results." His recipes don't look like the fender of a NASCAR. Are we all doomed to failure?
Poor Alton has it all wrong, apparently, cooking is not about understanding techniques or food science it is about buying the right brand name product. That nasty crack in your cheesecake isn't because you forgot to bake it in a water bath but because you used off-brand cream cream.
So, if you use AB's homemade mayo instead of Kraft's will Aunt Sandy's recipe fail? Like someone who'd take the time to make homemade mayo would use it in on of her recipes. Just trying to wrap my head around her thinking, here.
Sheesh, Sandy, stop spending your time with the tablescapes a get a clue.
This brings me to being grateful and thankful for Alton. The biggest appeal of Good Eats, for me, is the teaching element of the show. Watching AB has improved my cooking so much. I understand what happens in the cooking process and when I do mess up, how to fix it. Why? The brands I use? Hell no. Because Alton has explained a technique or has given me the scientific reason for the cause. I've been informed about cooking rather than given a recipe to follow.
Francis Bacon said, "knowledge is power." Good Eats would be an excellent example. Alton gives me knowledge and, in turn, I reap the benefits with confidence in the kitchen and lots of good eats. I know so much more than the one recipe from his show or cookbook. I'm not mindlessly following the directions and buying only the brand name products listed. No, I understand chemical reactions, the hows and whys, what heat does to food and proper technique. Maybe that's too brainy for some to understand.
I can only hope thinking that brought us the likes of
Semi-Homemade doesn't filter further into the Food Network's programming. Shows of high caliber like AB makes are few and far between on the network these days. That's sad.
So, I'm grateful and thankful AB is here to teach us and entertain at the same time. Thank you Alton for everything you do! :D